Extreme Gapping
Posted by Neal on November 21, 2008
“I can’t believe you put up with me,” my wife said.
“Nor I you me,” I replied.
She burst into laughter. After all, it’s pretty funny to imagine that she might have trouble putting up with me.
Gapping is a kind of nonparallel coordination in which two clauses are coordinated, each having the same main verb, and the verb is omitted from the second clause. Here’s an example:
Jim ordered a milkshake, and Kim (ordered) a beer.
If the subject and direct object in the verbless clause are pronouns, we end up with the somewhat unusual case of an entire clause consisting of pronouns:
Jim: I love you.
Kim: And I (love) you.
But I’d never heard a gapping sentence with both a main verb and an embedded verb omitted in the second clause, until I heard myself saying
Nor (can) I (believe) you (put up with) me.
Have any of you encountered bilevel gapping in the wild?
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
: 
viola said
Awwwe, sweet lovings expressed without verbs.
)
Ran said
Not only can I not find any examples of bi-level gapping, but more generally, I can’t seem to find any examples of embedded-clause gapping.
Picker Uppers and Putter Upper Withers « Literal-Minded said
[...] No need for her to take offense. After all, it’s well known between us that we are each other’s putter upper withers. [...]
There Was Supposed to Be a Gap! « Literal-Minded said
[...] erased. This is an example of a kind of coordination called gapping, which I wrote about in this post. So I’m expecting the last item in the coordination to be another clause with a gap instead [...]